Forbidden Fantasies (Erotica)

I let Erica walk in front of me for obvious reasons. Her ass looked like it wanted to eat her shorts, and I admired the curve of her exposed flesh that peeked out below her tight shorts. Strangely enough though, I wasn’t sporting a raging boner as I ogled her body. Sure, I was still aroused by her. She was one of the most beautiful women I had ever seen. But my mind was clear, and I was able to just enjoy the sight and presence of her without the teenager-like hormones dictating what they wanted me to do to the curvy goddess.

Maybe Mel was onto something.

I entered the kitchen behind Erica to see all of my siblings sitting around the small breakfast table. A huge spread of food was laid out, and it must have taken Amanda all morning to make it. My raven-haired oldest sister gave me a pleasant smile as I came in and gestured for me to take the seat beside her, which also put me next to Emily. The brunette twin didn’t look my way though. And her outfit choice of baggy pyjama pants and a large band t-shirt spoke volumes of her mood this morning. Her usual bright smile and sparkling eyes were vacant now as she forked scrambled eggs into her mouth methodically.Content is © 2024 NôvelDrama.Org.

I did this to her. So, I would fix it.

Mel gave me an intense-eyebrow arching-look as I took the seat opposite her, beside Emily. Then she purposefully cut into a lone sausage on her plate. The fact she didn’t really eat red meat meant she had been saving that sausage for a single purpose.

“Good morning everyone,” I said, looking at my siblings.

Everyone offered their greetings, even Emily. Although hers were more mumbled and she still didn’t look my way. I got a purposeful look from each of my sisters, and I knew they wanted me to fix what had happened between Emily and me. Each of them knew something had happened, even if they didn’t know exact details. I started eating as I mulled over what I should do as the conversation around the table started up. I mostly tuned my siblings out as I considered how to patch things up with Emily.

All Amanda wanted was for her sister to be happy. But did she suspect what me and Emily were on track to do? Even if I kept it as PG as possible, I could see it in Emily’s gorgeous green eyes every time she looked at me.

Mel wanted me to make it up to her twin sister, and from the encounter we just had and the things she said about monogamy, her thoughts on how were quite simple. Although… Emily was a virgin. Erica had told me that when she warned me away from our younger sister. But I had a feeling that was more out of jealousy than anything. Especially not some aversion to us sleeping together because we were blood related.

I started to really think about what I wanted and what I should do. Like… really think. Since I’d arrived here, I had been in a perpetual state of arousal that was either clouding my thoughts or made me think I was just horny and couldn’t make a clear decision. But… Mel had helped, just as she said she would. I felt clear-headed and able to see the amazing women around me for who they were. It could be this genetic thing she spoke about, but it wasn’t just their looks that made me love them.

“Emily,” I turned to face my sister. “Can we go somewhere to have a chat?”

“Why?” she replied, not looking up from her food.

“Please?” I pleaded.

She finally looked at me, and I saw the sadness and hurt in her eyes immediately. It broke my heart to see those emotions, especially since it was because of me.

“Okay.”

I gave the others a quick glance, seeing a small smile of approval from Amanda. A look of curiosity from Erica. And a grin from Mel as she stabbed her knife into the uneaten sausage. The last was slightly unsettling.

I followed Emily into the living room to the sound of soft conversation starting up once more from the kitchen. Emily turned to face me and was able to meet my eyes with hers. I had gone over what I needed to say to her again and again in my head. But nothing sounded right. I was never great with words and I was worried anything I said right now might sound false and empty.

I took two steps closer to Emily to close the distance between us. Then I wrapped my arms around her in a big hug. She let out a surprised gasp as I pulled her against me, but then her arms squeezed tightly around me as she returned the embrace.

“I’m so sorry I pushed you away,” I said, kissing the top of her head. “I was confused and worried I was being a bad influence on you.”

Emily didn’t reply, but she did press her face into the crook of my neck as she melted into my arms. We stood there in silence for a few minutes, just enjoying the feel of one-another. I loosened my hold on her when I felt her arms slide from around my back to rest on my hips, and we separated just enough for me to look into her beautiful green eyes.

“What changed your mind?” she asked in a whisper.

“Mel may have threatened to castrate me,” I laughed.

“Is that all,” Emily giggled.

“No,” I shook my head. “She helped me realise how stupid I was for fighting against all this. I’m not accustomed to having sisters or a big family and I didn’t know how to act. What we were doing was considered wrong by modern society and would be frowned upon. But I really don’t care what others think. I just want you, Mel, Amanda and Erica to be happy.”

“Mel was always the smart one,” Emily smiled. “So… what happens now?”

“I don’t know,” I sighed, not wanting to reveal what had happened between her twin and I earlier. “I know you have feelings for me-as I do you-but I’m not sure if I want to act upon them. All I know is I never want to hurt you again.”

Emily and I locked eyes for quite some time before she nodded, then gave me a small smile. “I don’t know what to do either. I know the way I feel about you isn’t normal, but I can’t help it. What do you say we just take it a day at a time?”

“That sounds like a plan to me.”

I pulled Emily into another quick hug, but then she surprised me by kissing me on the lips. Instinctively I cupped her face with one hand as I returned her kiss. A kiss that was much more passionate than any we’d shared before. I felt her tongue slide into my mouth and meet my own as our bodies pressed tightly together. My fingers worked through the strands of her hair and clutched the back of her neck as our tongues wrestled for dominance for what must have been a solid five minutes. Finally, we came up for air, both of us breathing heavily and my dick riding up against her stomach.

“Sorry about that,” I said, indicating to my crotch.

“It’s okay,” she smiled. “It’s a normal reaction. And a flattering one considering what I’m wearing.”

I pushed Emily out to arms-length and let my eyes roam over her baggy clothes. Then I gave my eyebrows a little wiggle. “You’d look great in anything.”

“Idiot,” Emily rolled her eyes. But she smiled widely. “Let’s get back.”

Emily and I returned to a very quiet kitchen. Amanda, Erica and Mel all stared at us as we took our seats. Emily had a terrible poker face, and the wide smile plastered on her beautiful face was evidence that we’d made up. Amanda visibly relaxed and gave me a smile, then she frowned a little. Whilst Erica looked between me and our younger sister with a curious look. Mel just nodded at me, then stabbed the cut sausage for good measure.